How boards create the conditions for candid deliberation
Many directors will know the moment. The meeting has closed, the papers are packed away, and two colleagues fall into step on the way to the lift. One of them says what she held back at the table, that the revenue forecast looked generous and nobody tested it. The other agrees. By the time they reach the street, the concern has been shared, and the board itself has never heard it.
A recent study of Dutch boards describes a moment very like this one. A director recalled a meeting in which the chair offered an opinion early. Colleagues appeared to adopt that view or hold back their own, and concern about the chair’s influence moved into a private conversation after the meeting [1]. Reading that account, I kept thinking about the distance between what a director thinks during a meeting and what reaches the table.
That distance is shaped, meeting by meeting, by how a chair responds when a concern does surface. Suppose a director questions the revenue assumption behind a proposal. The chair can give that concern a clear route into the deliberation by setting out the assumption, looking at the evidence for it and recording what the board concluded. Each response like this teaches directors something about what they can raise next time, and a board’s confidence in its decisions rests on how well it draws on the knowledge, experience and observations around the table.
It also helps to look at how agreement forms. When a decision passes, a chair can ask which assumptions the board tested, how alternative interpretations were considered and what led directors to support it. The answers show whether the board’s confidence has a firm basis or simply reflects the first view in the room.
The study comes from Marilieke Engbers and Svetlana Khapova, who observed 19 meetings across 17 Dutch two-tier boards and conducted 113 retrospective interviews with directors. In a two-tier structure, executive management sits apart from a supervisory board, and their research looked at supervisory board deliberation, largely in housing corporations. Published in 2026 in the Journal of Management and Governance, it explores the relationship between what directors think privately and what they contribute in the meeting [1]. It is qualitative work in a particular governance setting, so each of us has to judge how far it speaks to our own boards, and I found plenty in it that does.
Engbers and Khapova call the pattern a Spiral of the Unsaid. Tensions and differing assumptions go unspoken, drift into informal conversations and build up over time [1]. The spiral keeps turning because each director reads past exchanges for clues about what they can say next, and whatever they then say, or leave out, becomes the next exchange their colleagues read in turn.
Beneath the spiral sit what the authors call implicit governance paradigms, the underlying assumptions each director brings about governance itself. When those assumptions differ, directors interpret the same interaction in different ways, and the difference tends to stay unspoken in the meeting and surface afterwards in informal conversations [1]. Once the assumptions are brought into the discussion, the board has something concrete to examine together.
The director in that Dutch boardroom was describing the spiral in motion. When the chair’s view arrives early, colleagues read the conditions for contributing, and a concern can leave the room before the board has had a chance to examine it [1]. Drawing on these findings, I propose three meeting practices that give a concern a clear route from one director’s private thinking into the board’s collective judgement. Each works on something a chair already shapes, the order in which a conversation unfolds, the response a concern receives and the room a board gives itself to reflect.
The first practice begins before anyone offers a view. When a chair opens an item with the decision required, the evidence available and the assumptions that deserve examination, directors share a task from the outset. It helps to say whether the item calls for exploration, advice or approval, so everyone knows what kind of contribution is being sought.
Before offering your own assessment, try inviting each director to identify one assumption they think needs examining. Recording those assumptions gives the discussion its structure, and in the revenue proposal it might bring expected customer demand into view early. Given what the study found about a chair’s early opinion, this sequence is worth trying, and the record lets you see its effect on your own board.
A useful opening question is
What do we need to understand to make a considered decision on this proposal?
A question like this turns attention to the work of deliberation itself. Directors can sort out what the evidence supports, where judgement is needed and which issues need investigating.
As the discussion moves, the chair can keep that frame alive by watching the group, noticing who has contributed, which perspective is shaping the conversation and whether the pace is helping the board examine the proposal. Those observations can guide the next invitation or question.
Once the frame is set, the second practice keeps the board’s reasoning open. A chair can make alternative interpretations an ordinary part of the agenda with one question.
What evidence would change our view?
It invites directors to bring the assumptions beneath the emerging decision into view and to consider the circumstances in which their judgement might shift.
Noticing when a view deserves another look draws on a capacity my own research has explored. In our survey of 185 Australian directors, my research colleagues Justin Brienza and Vince Murdoch and I identified two dimensions of mindfulness associated with wisdom in the boardroom. Embodied Mindfulness is awareness of our own internal experience, and Group Attunement is awareness of group dynamics and the board as a whole [2]. These findings come from directors describing themselves, so I offer the two dimensions here as prompts for reflection during deliberation.
In practice, a director might feel a flicker of tension when a risk receives only brief attention, or an urge to agree while still weighing the reasoning. A chair might notice agreement arriving fast, or a change in how colleagues respond to questions. Impressions like these can have several explanations, so they serve the board as questions to investigate. Be specific about what you observed, such as the time spent on the revenue assumption, and ask colleagues how they assessed the evidence.
Examined this way, an impression becomes useful to everyone. A director can explain what prompted the concern, identify the assumption involved and ask what evidence would help assess it, which gives colleagues something concrete to consider. The chair might ask, “What prompted your concern, and which part of the recommendation should we examine?” and then give the director time to explain before inviting the executive responsible for the proposal to respond. In this way candour becomes part of the board’s working practice.
Sometimes a concern needs time the agenda has left no room for, and the third practice makes that time available. A board can agree in advance that any director may ask for clarification, additional evidence or time to consider a material issue. That agreement gives everyone a legitimate way to influence the pace of deliberation, and a simple request may be enough.
Can we pause and clarify the assumption behind this recommendation?
From there, the board can establish which assumption is in question, how it affects the recommendation and when a decision is required. If resolving the revenue assumption could change the decision, agree the evidence needed and a date for reconsideration, and check the board’s governing procedures to see whether the chair can defer the item or a board resolution is required.
A pause earns its place when it leads somewhere clear. Before closing the item, the chair can ask one final question.
What concern, assumption or alternative interpretation still needs examination, and how will we address it?
Agree who will take responsibility, what information is required and when the item will return, and record those commitments alongside the decision.
We can begin our next meeting with one significant decision. Look back at how it was framed, how alternative interpretations were examined and how any request for a pause was handled. Then agree one adjustment, record who will carry it out and review its effect at the following meeting. Each small adjustment like this gives the next concern a reason to come to the table, so the conversation by the lift can happen in the boardroom, where the whole board can hear it.
Engbers, M., & Khapova, S. N. (2026). How misalignment of implicit governance paradigms shapes the spiral of the unsaid in boards of directors. Journal of Management and Governance. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10997-026-09794-y
King, E., Brienza, J. P., & Murdoch, V. (2026). A new framework for measuring two key dimensions of mindfulness in the boardroom. In D. Rooney, J. P. Brienza, A. Intezari, & E. King (Eds.), Elgar encyclopedia of wisdom research (pp. 380–398). Edward Elgar. https://doi.org/10.4337/9781035302628